Proxy fights, the universal proxy, and ISS and Glass Lewis
By SuperdayReps · Michigan Ross Undergrad | Wharton MBA · ex-Citi | ex-Greenhill · Former Head Mentor at a Leading IB Prep Service
11 min read · updated November 18, 2026
An activist that owns 5% of a company cannot elect anyone with its own shares. It has to persuade the owners of the other 95%. A proxy fight is that persuasion, run as an election, and the people who decide most elections are a handful of large institutions and the two firms that advise them. This lesson covers how the vote works, what a fight looks like, and who ISS and Glass Lewis are.
How shareholders vote
Public companies hold an annual meeting at which shareholders elect directors and vote on other items, such as executive pay and shareholder proposals. Very few shareholders attend. Almost everyone votes by proxy, meaning they authorize someone to cast their vote at the meeting as they instruct.
Before the meeting, the company files a with the SEC (form DEF 14A) and sends it with a proxy card. The statement describes each director nominee, executive pay and every other item on the ballot. Only holders on the , set weeks before the meeting, can vote.
Two facts about who votes shape every fight:
- Institutions vote almost all their shares. Asset managers have a duty to vote on behalf of their clients, so they vote nearly everything.
- Retail investors often do not. Individuals who hold through a broker vote a much smaller share of their stock, and in any director election a broker cannot vote shares its clients gave no instructions on. A company with a large retail base starts a fight with many votes it may never collect.
Keep reading
The rest of this lesson is free with an account
There's about 8 more minutes of Proxy fights, the universal proxy, and ISS and Glass Lewis below this, plus every other lesson in Activism & Defense. Free account, no card.
Any partner school .edu
Frequently asked
- Who are ISS and Glass Lewis?
- They are the two big proxy advisory firms. Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS), founded in 1985, has been majority owned by Deutsche Börse since 2021. Glass Lewis, founded in 2003, has been owned by Peloton Capital Management and Stephen Smith since 2021. Together they have more than 90% of the US market for proxy advice.
- Who hires proxy advisors, and what do they do?
- Institutional investors, such as asset managers and pension funds, hire them. They analyze every item on the ballot at thousands of shareholder meetings, recommend how to vote under a standard policy or the client's own policy, and run the platforms many institutions use to cast and record their votes. ISS also sells governance consulting to companies through a separate unit, which critics call a conflict of interest.
- What is the universal proxy rule?
- SEC Rule 14a-19, in force for meetings after August 31, 2022, requires both sides in a contested director election to list all nominees, the company's and the dissident's, on one proxy card. Shareholders voting by proxy can now mix and match, which makes it easier for an activist to win one or two seats and lets it target specific directors.
- Why do proxy advisors matter so much in a proxy fight?
- Because neither side usually owns enough to win, the institutions in the middle decide the vote, and many of them follow or weigh heavily what ISS and Glass Lewis recommend. Smaller institutions often lack the staff to study each contest. Both sides make their case to the advisors, and a recommendation can move a large block of votes.
