Private Capital Advisory

Conflicts, fairness opinions and the secondaries market

By SuperdayReps · Michigan Ross Undergrad | Wharton MBA · ex-Citi | ex-Greenhill · Former Head Mentor at a Leading IB Prep Service

9 min read · updated November 12, 2026

Lesson 3 ended on the uncomfortable part of a continuation vehicle: the GP is on both sides of the deal. This lesson is about what that means, what the industry has built to manage it, and how to talk about the secondaries market as a whole, which is the other thing PCA interviewers like to ask about.

The conflict, mapped

In a normal sale, the seller wants a high price and the buyer wants a low one, and they are different people with different advisors. In a CV, everyone is connected to the same GP.

PartyWants the priceWhy
Selling LPsHighThey are cashing out at that price.
Rolling LPsLowerThey are, in effect, buying in again at that price, and a higher price means more carry paid to the GP on the stake they keep.
New investors and the leadLowTheir return depends on what they pay.
The GP, as manager of the old fundHighMore profit on the sale means more carry.
The GP, as manager of the CVLowA lower starting value makes future carry easier to earn, and the fees continue either way.
The GP's advisorA deal that closesIt is usually paid mostly on success, by the GP.

The GP also knows the company far better than any LP. It has the forecasts, it sits on the board, it knows why the company is being kept. That information gap is the real problem: an LP asked to sell or roll in a few weeks is deciding with less knowledge than the party proposing the deal.

Key insight

The question every protection is trying to answer is: how does a selling LP know the price is fair when the party setting up the sale is also, in a way, the buyer? The answer is to bring in outsiders who have no reason to help the GP: competing bidders, an independent valuation, and LP representatives who can say no.

Keep reading

The rest of this lesson is free with an account

There's about 6 more minutes of Conflicts, fairness opinions and the secondaries market below this, plus every other lesson in Private Capital Advisory. Free account, no card.

Any partner school .edu

Frequently asked

Why is a continuation vehicle a conflict of interest?
Because the GP is on both sides of the deal. It manages the old fund that is selling and the new vehicle that is buying, so it can benefit from a high price (more carry on the sale) and from a low price (an easier path to carry in the new vehicle, and fees either way). The selling LPs and the new investors want opposite prices, and the GP knows more about the company than either.
What does a fairness opinion say?
It is a letter from a financial advisor, backed by valuation work, saying that the price in a transaction is fair, from a financial point of view, to a named party, usually the fund or its GP. It does not say whether the deal is a good idea, whether a better deal exists, or whether every term is fair, and it relies on information and projections the GP supplies.
What protects LPs in a GP-led secondary?
A competitive process to find the lead investor, consent from the LP advisory committee where the fund's agreement requires it, a fairness opinion, enough time and information for each LP to choose between selling and rolling, a fair default if an LP does not answer, and disclosure of the GP's conflicts. ILPA publishes guidance on all of these, which is recommended practice rather than law.
What is the difference between a subscription line and a NAV loan?
A subscription line is a short-term loan to a fund backed by its LPs' unfunded commitments, used early in the fund's life to bridge capital calls. A NAV loan is backed by the value of the fund's investments, used later in its life to raise cash without selling companies.
LearnAI